The Euro zone summit disappoints and so does Germany’s economy

Yesterday saw some very disappointing results from the Euro-summit in Brussels. Regular readers will be aware that I set some criteria for a successful summit. Please look at my article from yesterday for my criteria for a successful action from Euro zone leaders and my view on the dangers/moral hazards which faced them. There is one danger which I shall repeat below.

1. That Europe’s politicians seeing the impact of their meeting on financial markets lose their sense of urgency and dither. Let us face it being politicians they probably enjoy the limelight and illusion of importance but they must resist this temptation and come up with decisive action.

What we actually got was mere promises. Both the German Chancellor and the French President used the same phrase “we have sent/delivered a clear political signal”. To which my reply is that the situation needs more than a signal. It looks as though we may know more after the Econfin meeting which finishes on the 16th February. However Angela Merkel did say they would look at the situation again in March. So my call for decisive action is not going to be achieved. As an aside such correlated phrases make me wonder how much time they spent on economics and how much they spent on media presentation/public relations.

What do we know?

There will be money loaned by Germany and France to Greece. This will be to help it finance its debts of which some 40 billion Euros of issuance will be required by the middle of this year. In addition the International Monetary Fund (IMF) will police the Greek deficit reduction programme and maybe whilst it is there it can cast its eye over Greek statistics.

There is a technical issue here which has not been explained in the press which is important. There are rules for the cost of IMF money. In the case of Greece if she borrows more than $4.2 billion (the ratio is her IMF quota multiplied by three) the IMF would charge an interest rate of 4.25% for the money. This leads to the following conclusions.

1. It is currently cheaper for Greece to borrow from the IMF than it is for it to borrow from the markets.

2. We can measure how tough the Euro zone is actually going to be with Greece by the rate of interest she is charged on the money they loan her. In other words we can compare it with the cost of IMF funding. It will be interesting to see what this measure tells us and whether it tells the same story as politicians words.

Potential Moral Hazard

An interest rate below that charged by the IMF would mean that other Euro zone countries suffering from fiscal incontinence would be disincentivised from tightening their budgets.

Market Reaction

As the news filtered out the Euro and equity markets fell presumably disappointed by the news (or perhaps lack of it…). Later on American equity markets rallied and European leaders must be grateful for the large share buy-back programme announced by Phillip Marlboro ( US $ 12 billion). In terms of bond markets  I have used the German ten-year bund as a benchmark and last night’s comparative closes are shown below.

Greece +2.75%,Ireland+1.38%, Portugal+1.19%, and Spain +0.79%

The Greek two-year government bond I have been following now yields 5.08%. So there have been improvements here although the cautionary note is that much of this took place before the announcement and perhaps the full effect of the announcement will take time.


Whatever the German Chancellor Angela Merkel means by ” determined and coördinated action” is unclear and that is the problem. The economic crisis has been littered by politicians making statements which they believed to be sufficient in themselves. For example Henry Paulson the US Treasury Secretary felt that simply announcing that he had the power to bail out Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac would save them in late 2008, it didn’t and the US taxpayer had to ride to their rescue. So perhaps it was predictable but it is also disappointing.

Germany today

Some concerning economic news has come out of Germany today. Her statistical office has published figures this morning stating that her economy did not grow at all in the fourth quarter of 2009. Now this is a first estimate and I counsel caution in dealing with all first estimates of economic figures. But Germany is such a bell weather not only for Europe but also the world that such a number is worrying.

As I have stated above Germany’s help is required for Greece and maybe other Euro zone members. But there is a deeper problem. I wrote on this subject in an article on parallels with the 1930s on the 18th January 2010. Many countries are hoping for export led growth and as a country which is a net exporter Germany is one of the countries which can buy these exports. If she is not doing well it is hard to see the German consumer helping much to correct this particular example of a world imbalance. This is bad news for everyone.

There was more hopeful news from France which grew by 0.6% in the fourth quarter but this only partly offsets the German numbers. Later numbers for the whole of the Euro zone in the 4th quarter of 2009 showed growth to be only 0.1% in line with the UK.

The UK’s government bond yields

As measured against the German benchmark our ten-year bond yields have edged higher this year. As of last night’s close it was +0.78% and we opened the year at +0.61%. Now we have almost the same spread as Spain albeit mostly because of the improvement in Spain’s perceived situation.

The end of Quantitative Easing was always likely to see our government bond yields drift higher. Last year we bought all our issuance off ourselves (in fact we actually bought more than we sold) and this year we have to find a buyer elsewhere. I do not expect this to lead to an immediate calamity but we have £225.1 billion of government debt to sell this year according to the Debt Management Office. The situation is complicated by the General Election expected in May as a political change is likely and markets may well be waiting for this. Sooner or later though this will cause indigestion and yields will rise in my view.

Put another way if we stay as we are then in relative terms our issuance this year will cost us an extra £400 million approximately in interest. This will be every year until the bonds mature. To put this into perspective the political debate over free personal care for the elderly in England this week has led to a figure of £670 million being quoted as a cost.


2 thoughts on “The Euro zone summit disappoints and so does Germany’s economy

  1. It seems that some other observers believe the Euro may be on the point of break-up. In the Daily Mail today Society Generale’s Albert Edwards, Mats Persson, Director of the Open Europe think-tank and Professor Martin Feldstein of Harvard university are all reported as taking that position.

    “The European single currency is facing an ‘inevitable break-up’ a leading French bank claimed yesterday. Strategists at Paris-based Société Générale said that any bailout of the stricken Greek economy would only provide ‘sticking plasters’ to cover the deep- seated flaws in the eurozone bloc.

    The stark warning came as the euro slipped further on the currency markets and dire growth figures raised the prospect of a ‘double-dip’ recession in the embattled zone.

    The bailout of Greece will only act as a ‘sticking plaster’ for the Euro crisis, the bank warned yesterday

    Claims that the euro could be headed for total collapse are particularly striking when they come from one of the oldest and largest banks in France – a core founder-member.

    In a note to investors, SocGen strategist Albert Edwards said: ‘My own view is that there is little “help” that can be offered by the other eurozone nations other than temporary, confidence-giving “sticking plasters” before the ultimate denouement: the break-up of the eurozone.’

    He added: ‘Any “help” given to Greece merely delays the inevitable break-up of the eurozone.’

    The alarming claim came a day after European Union leaders promised ‘determined and co-ordinated’ action to shore up Greece’s tattered public finances, but disappointed traders by failing to provide specifics.

    Further details are expected early next week, but markets were in high anxiety yesterday amid fears political divisions among rich eurozone members could derail any rescue.

    The euro slid almost 1 per cent to $1.357 yesterday, meaning it has lost 10 per cent of its value since November. The pound rose to 1.14 euros.

    The French bank’s warning was echoed by Mats Persson, Director of the Open Europe think-tank, which campaigns for reforms in Brussels.

    He said: ‘The eurozone is facing a fully-fledged crisis. The Greece episode has made it painfully clear how flawed the euro project was from the very beginning.

    ‘Even if Greece receives a one-off bailout it would not solve the real problem, which is the huge differences in competitiveness between the eurozone’s richest and poorest members.

    ‘If these differences are to be evened out, the EU would need a single budget and common taxes so it can redistribute resources.

    Mr Edwards argued that Portugal, Ireland, Greece and Spain are too economically weak to withstand the rigours of eurozone membership.

    Countries that are highly uncompetitive are normally able to slash interest rates and devalue their currencies to prop up their economies.

    But this is not possible within the euro, given its one-size-fits-all economic governance.

    The implication is that weak, peripheral eurozone members will have to suffer years of painful deflation and tumbling living standards, as well as draconian budget cuts, in order to adjust.

    Harvard University Professor Martin Feldstein, a long-standing sceptic on the euro, yesterday said the single currency ‘isn’t working’ because member governments have no incentive to keep their public debts under control.

    ‘There’s too much incentive for countries to run up big deficits as there’s no feedback until a crisis,’ he said. ”

    Read more:

  2. If this was happening to Michigan, Bernanke would’ve forcefully squashed this bug long ago. This aggressiveness is a big reason why these speculators don’t attack California and Michigan as they do Greece. I give it two weeks before Greece cries for mercy, and by the time they do, someone else will be in trouble.. Portugal most likely. The smartest way to handle this is to let the IMF deal with it; they will dole out the help in bits and pieces as Greece slowly slashes spending and raises revenues.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.