Moody’s downgrade affects Greek bonds and Spain has problems too

This week has seen various developments in the UK economy and I wrote on those on Monday and Tuesday. However there have been moves and developments in the euro zone too particularly in the sphere of peripheral sovereign bonds,credit ratings and inter-bank markets. Sound familiar? Interestingly this time the euro is rallying whilst these play out as opposed to falling and just as interestingly so are global stock markets which have just had seven days of rises overall,albeit hidden slightly in the UK because we do not have a FTSE 99 index. Those (journalists) who are absolutely confident that some events led to other might do well to observe this fact that there is not the direct causal link that many of them have implied. On the subject of stock markets after last nights more than 200 point rise in the Dow Jones Industrial Average it is now 21 out of the last 30 days that have seen a triple digit move on a closing basis. Now that I do see as a symptom of these times, and not particularly a good one.


I have written over the last week or ten days about the way that Greek government bond yields were edging higher again and after going above 8% at the ten-year maturity had reached 8.3%. Considering the scale of euro zone firepower with the “shock and awe” SPV in the background and outright buying of Greek government bonds by the European Central Bank in the foreground you might think that this was not an inspiring result and I would agree with you.

Late on Monday the Moodys ratings agency as I mentioned yesterday downgraded Greece’s government bond rating by four notches from A3 to Ba1, and it also reduced Greece’s short-term issuer rating from prime to not prime. Moody’s offered some analysis of the situation with its downgrade according to the Financial Times.

“The Ba1 rating reflects our analysis of the balance of the strengths and risks associated with the Euro zone/IMF support package. The package effectively eliminates any near-term risk of a liquidity-driven default and encourages the implementation of a credible, feasible, and incentive-compatible set of structural reforms, which have a high likelihood of stabilizing debt service requirements at manageable levels,” says Sarah Carlson, Vice President-Senior Analyst in Moody’s Sovereign Risk Group and lead analyst for Greece. “Nevertheless, the macroeconomic and implementation risks associated with the programme are substantial and more consistent with a Ba1 rating.” She is unconvinced over time how the reforms will play out and adds ““This uncertainty represents a risk that leads Moody’s to believe that Greece’s creditworthiness is now consistent with a Ba1 rating, a rating which incorporates a greater, albeit, low risk of default.”

So Moodys is afraid of the d word or default. In other words the question it is posing is what happens after the euro zone and ECB pack their bags and go home? A deeper question might be can they go home? However only events playing out can answer this question. On a related topic there is an IMF team in Athens right now going through Greece’s national accounts as part of the conditionality of the aid given her. If they should decide that she is not fulfilling her side of the bargain then the next payment of funds from the EU/IMF support package due in August will not be paid. Some more excitable blogs think it is likely that this will happen. Personally I feel that the IMF auditors will be under enormous political pressure and  if they do uncover problems the result will be that it is hushed up for now  and further pressure will be put on Greece to comply. There are a lot of vested European political interests at play here.

Implications of Moodys move.

1.Greek government bonds will  attract an extra 5 per cent penalty when banks use them as security for ECB funds because of Moody’s action. The extra haircut means commercial banks will receive less money for Greek bonds than for bonds from any other euro zone nation. An irony of this is that to maintain their current positions they will have to deposit even more Greek government bonds with the ECB, which will further weaken its credit position on average. In case you are wondering it is estimated that Greek commercial banks have deposited some 85 billion Euros of Greek government bonds with the ECB in return for funding.

2. Moody’s move forced some bond investors to offload the country’s debt. You see some investment funds track indices that have credit rating limits that no longer permit the holding of Greek government bonds. For example they will not be eligible for Barclays Capital’s Global Aggregate, Global Treasury, Euro Aggregate and Euro Treasury Indexes. In something of an irony Greek government bonds will be eligible for some emerging market and junk indices,however this is hardly a source of pride as it returns Greece to where it was when it joined the Euro 9 years ago! Also the net effect will be sales of Greek bonds.


The effect of these moves has been quite striking. Last night according to Reuters Greek ten-year government bond yields closed at 9.35% which is back to crisis levels. Greece also has a three -year government bond which is used as a benchmark and this closed at a yield of 9.5%. On May 10th after the announcement of the 750 billion Euro SPV and the commencement of ECB purchases of peripheral sovereign debt the respective yields were 8.26% and 9.09% respectively. This is not quite my definition of “shock and awe” anymore and poses a real challenge to euro zone policymakers.

On the subject of euro zone policymakers regular readers will be aware that no action in this crisis can take place without an official from the euro zone believing that spouting absolute rubbish will improve the situation. In this instance step forward Olli Rehn.

“Moody’s decision does not in any way take into account Greek commitments or the negative consequences, which were considerably reduced following the adoption of the (bailout) programme,”

If you simply read their statement above you can see that Moodys specifically mention that they did.

As to ratings agencies and Moodys in particular then the timing of this move does them no great credit (and of course they are starting from a low base). After all if Greece is Ba1 with European support and financing what was it back in April when it had no European support and had taken fewer austerity measures? The only possible conclusion is that Greece was weaker but Moodys did nothing. In a way this is an apt analogy for the failures of ratings agencies.

Spain and the effects of contagion

I have written several times recently about the way Spain is being sucked increasingly into the sovereign debt crisis, for example I wrote about her cajas or savings banks on the 24th May and her general situation on the 31st May. In general her banks are struggling to be able to fund themselves in inter-bank markets particularly if you exclude the big two Santander and BBVA. There was some official acknowledgement of the problem on Monday when Carlos Ocana who is Spain’s Treasury secretary said that the credit freeze affecting Spanish banks and corporations was “definitely a problem”.

Perhaps the clearest sign of the stress in the country’s financial sector is the fact that its banks are borrowing record amounts from the European Central Bank because they are unable to raise funds in the private markets. It is being reported that Spanish banks have raised a record €85.6 billion in ECB funding. To put this into context this is double the amount lent to them before the collapse of Lehman Brothers in September 2008 and 16.5 % of net euro zone loans offered by the ECB which compares to the fact that they are 11% of the banking system by size.

Just at this moment the German newspaper Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung joined the debate and suggested that the euro zone was planning a bailout for Spain. This is hardly going to improve things although it perhaps ignores the fact that so far Spain as a country has a debt to GDP ratio which is much better than Greece’s.

However Spanish government bond yields have pushed higher this week and her ten-year yields are now 4.8% which is 2.11% over that of Germany’s equivalent. Again if we compare to the “shock and awe ” date of May 10th they were 4% and that is quite a difference. So far this week Spain has raised some short-term money at a rates  around 0.7 and 0.9% higher than past issues of the same maturity. So not good but not a disaster. We will find out more later this week as she has some longer dated bonds to issue.


It is starting to feel as if the problems which originated in her property and banking markets are beginning slowly to catch up with Spain. There is an irony that her new austerity programme is by weakening prospective economic growth  not helping her image as much as it might. So far she is able to cope with the situation but the policymakers of the euro zone do have a problem with her and Greece as in spite of the ECB buying 6.5 billion Euros of peripheral government debt over the past week yields are rising.

As to the SPV my thoughts turn to a problem with it that I wrote about from the beginning. Spain is responsible for 53.9 billion Euros of the funding. Should she have to draw from the fund how does that work exactly? If conditions continue to deteriorate I suspect that this question will occur to others too.


10 thoughts on “Moody’s downgrade affects Greek bonds and Spain has problems too

    • Hi Mr.K
      Yes Mr. Strauss-Kahn’s visit on Friday has fired up the rumour mill somewhat. I think that in a way the relevant number in the SPV is Spain’s share of 54 billion Euros and how that works….
      Also Spain has lent money to Greece as part of the 110 Euro bailout of her,will Greece now in effect lend to Spain as part of the SPV?

  1. Indeed, as andy observes, that is the price for negligence.

    Meanwhile, back in the UK, the OBR is reported in The Sunday Times as having put a somewhat different profile on the UK’s fiscal situation. ” The economy, more damaged by the banking crisis than previously admitted, will grow more weakly and may never fully recover, the new Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) said yesterday.

    The conclusion adds billions of pounds to the total that George Osborne must find if he is to restore the public finances to health.”

    Now that I do find increasingly worrying; but it at least seems to indicate, if there were still any doubt, that things are much worse than at first concluded? It seems this may be another example of neglected rolling crises leading to a much higher price, this time in the UK?

  2. I wonder to what degree French and German banks ( and others) have offloaded Greek,Portugese and Spanish government bonds on to the ECB, stemming market risks for themselves but transferring them to the ECB and,thereby, the citizens of the eurozone? Its as if ECB might/has become a bond bucket.

    I was reassured to see that OECD outlook didnt over emphasise the banking contagion risk from Greek asset losses toward French,German and US banks but pointed to challenges to bank capital if Portugese and Spanish assets ( not just sovereign bonds) sustained losses in addition. Presumably, this is where ECB have provided a partial loss buffer to the banking system.

  3. Interesting facts from BIS June 10 outlook on banking exposures – French and German banks’ exposures to private bank and non bank borrowers is significantly higher than to public sector borrowers in PIGS : $958bn at end of 09;

    what interested me was the following from BIS :

    French and German banks were not the only ones with large exposures to residents of euro area countries facing market pressures. Banks headquartered in the United Kingdom had larger exposures to Ireland ($230 billion) than did banks based in any other country. More than half of those ($128 billion) were to the non-bank private sector. UK banks also had sizeable exposures to residents of Spain ($140 billion), mostly to the non-bank private sector ($79 billion).

    How’s Ireland getting on?

    • Hi Shireblogger
      It would appear from the recent hearings that the debts of Anglo-Irish bank in the property arena are going to be every bit as bad as people feared which of course sooner or later will arrive at the Irish taxpayers door. At least NAMA (The Irish bad bank) is up and running and dealing with this which contrasts somewhat with the Spanish FROB.However when I was looking at Europe’s economic statistics earlier this week I did notice that Ireland’s inflation rate was the opposite outlier to Greece at -2.5% (measured as a 12 month average) and her month on month industrial output was -10.9% ( although it is a very erratic series). At least her unemployment rate at 13.2% hasn’t picked up too much so far but 2010/11 will be difficult.

  4. Hey y’ all,

    the quarterly report from the Bank for International Settlements is out,
    and Graph 3 on pg. 19 shows the exposures of the banks of different countries to the debts of the SGIPs. It puts numbers to the predicament of all involved (and perhaps the reasons for the timing of different countries’ change of tune).
    Meanwhile, in Greece, the press and the government are railing against them speculators (Moody’s that is). Greece is preparing to issue T-bills in July to roll over about 4 billion euros in short term debt that is coming due (Shaun had talked about the issuing of short term debt by Greece a few months ago). The T-bills will be 3-, 6-, and 12-month in duration. Greece has about 9 billion euros in short term debt, and, you guessed it, the EU/IMF funds do not cover it (there was a report regarding this in the Kathimerini of June 6, before the downgrade).
    Still in Greece, the government is preparing to issue more bonds, which will deposit in a couple of semi-public Savings and Loans (including the Postal one), in order to get funds to pay pension benefits for public sector retirees. Apparently, the EU/IMF funds do not cover these obligations either.
    The Greek government is also settling its 5+ billion euros debts to the hospital suppliers (some of it from 2005-2006) by issuing non-interest bearing negotiable bills maturing in 1-3 years (I guess in Californese and Illinoian these are called IOUs).


    • Hi John
      Thanks for the heads up on the BIS report which I took a look at. Also I do remember writng about the hospital/drug debts a while ago and have to confess if I was a drugs company then IOUs from Greece would make me somewhat nervous…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.