The Forward Misguidance of Mark Carney and the Bank of England continues

Yesterday was a rather extraordinary day at the Bank of England even by its standards. I do not mean in terms of the policy announcements as they were not only unchanged but were always likely to be that way. This is of course because it boxed itself in with its pronouncements of economic doom last summer leading to its Bank Rate cut and extra QE (Quantitative Easing). There was actually a technical announcement on the QE front about another Operation Twist style move.

the Committee agreed to re-invest the £11.6 billion of cash flows associated with the redemption of the January 2017 gilt held by the Asset Purchase Facility

If you think about an economy which the Bank of England now thinks will have 2% economic growth in 2017 and inflation heading above target soon that is simply completely inappropriate and wrong. It is a consequence of its silly “Sledgehammer” rhetoric which Mark Carney plainly feels is too embarrassing to reverse now.

Economic growth forecasts

The Bank of England and Mark Carney seem to be getting worse and worse at this. From yesterday’s MPC (Monetary Policy Committee) Minutes.

The preliminary estimate of GDP growth for 2016 Q4 had been 0.6%, the same rate of growth as had been registered in the previous two quarters, and 0.2 percentage points higher than expected at the time of the November 2016 Inflation Report. This, together with improvements in business survey output and expectations indicators, had led Bank staff to raise their GDP growth nowcast for 2017 Q1 to 0.5%, also 0.2 percentage points higher than in November.

Such things matter when the Forward Guidance had led to policy changes as we saw in August. In fact the situation is ever more woeful than that. Even the Financial Times which of course has lauded Mark Carney as a “rockstar” central banker could not avoid pointing out this reality.

The Bank of England upgraded UK growth forecasts significantly for the second time in six months on Thursday in the latest indication the central bank’s once-dire outlook for the economy after June’s Brexit vote has been proven overly pessimistic.

The bank said it now predicts gross domestic product will grow 2 per cent this year, the same as last year and up from 1.4 per cent forecast in November. Shortly after the referendum, the BoE predicted the economy would expand just 0.8 per cent.

The simple fact is that the UK consumer and if you look into the detail our female consumers behaved like they have in the past and carried on regardless. It is for the Bank of England to explain why it ignored UK economic history. Perhaps the way it is now packed with people I have described as Carney’s cronies?

Was this predictable?

Yes it was as I pointed out back then. From August 3rd last year on the day of ignominy for the Bank of England.

I would vote for unchanged policy as I waited to see how we respond to the lower value of the UK Pound £ which on the old rule of thumb has provided a move equivalent to a 2%  Bank Rate cut.

I repeated this view on BBC Radio Four’s Moneybox on the 17th of September when I debated with ex Bank of England staffer Professor Tony Yates who said “they did pretty much the right thing”. However it was kind yesterday of Mark Carney to confirm that I was indeed right all along.

Third, financial conditions in the UK remain supportive, underpinned by low risk-free rates, the 18% fall in sterling since its November 2015 peak, and lower credit spreads.

Mark Carney tries to take the credit for this

Perhaps the worst part of yesterday’s Inflation Report was the bit where Mark Carney tried to take the credit for the performance of the UK economy.

In part this reflects Bank of England policy actions, which have also helped lower the impact of uncertainty on activity.

He omitted to point out his own doom laden pronouncements which would hardly have helped uncertainty and he had another go at that yesterday.

This stronger projection doesn’t mean the referendum is without consequence………More broadly, the level of GDP is still expected to be 1½% lower in two years’ time than projected in May, despite the substantial easing of monetary, macroprudential and fiscal policies.

If we return to Governor Carney’s claims we see that we had a “bazooka” from a lower pound compared to a “pea shooter” from his Bank Rate cut as I pointed out on Moneybox. Indeed the Governor got himself into something of a mess at the press conference as he tried to take some of the credit for consumer resilience (debt fuelled growth) and then denied that there was much debt fuelled growth! So let us leave him in his own land of confusion.

Ivory Tower alert

We got some of this too as the woeful Bank of England forecasting effort saw this addition.

Specifically, the MPC now judges that the rate of unemployment the economy can achieve while being consistent with sustainable rates of wage growth to be around 4½%, down from around 5% previously.

This was such a hot potato that the subject was handed over to Deputy Governor Ben Broadbent to explain. Ben was obviously uncomfortable as he began speaking behind his hand in the manner of Jose Mourinho. He then tried to tell us he had been right all along which of course begged the question of why there was a change? Anyway we then did get a brief burst of honesty.

Forecasting is a hazardous business

It is for Ben!

Oh and remember when their Forward Guidance was that 7% unemployment was a significant level? Whatever happened to that….


Another problem is brewing here and this is in addition to the fact that it is going “higher and higher”. This from the Bank of England yesterday was simply wrong.

Beyond that, inflation is expected to increase further, peaking around 2.8% at the start of 2018, before falling gradually back to 2.4% in three years’ time.

As I have written many times on here that is too low as I expect it to rise above 3% due to the impact of the lower UK Pound £ and the higher price of crude oil. I recall Kristin Forbes of the Bank of England saying that she thought inflation would be pushed some 1.75% higher but now she seems to have done something of a U-Turn and decided it will be more like 0.75%. As the UK Pound £ has fallen further in the meantime that is quite a big change.


There is one aspect of Bank of England Forward Guidance which has in fact proved correct.

the appropriate level of Bank Rate is likely to be materially below the 5% level set on average by the Committee prior to the financial crisis.

I think we can say 0.25% is materially below 5%. But the rest of it has proven to be woeful. After all Mark Carney’s hints of a Bank Rate rise would fit an economy over 3 years into a growth phase and with inflation set to run above target. But of course all his hints and teases were followed by exactly the reverse or a Bank Rate cut.

As to the inflation forecast well this morning has brought the beginnings of a further critique of that as well. From the BBC.

Npower has announced one of the largest single price rises implemented by a “Big Six” supplier. The company will raise standard tariff electricity prices by 15% from 16 March, and gas prices by 4.8%. A typical dual fuel annual energy bill will rise by an average of 9.8%, or £109.

Also there is the media inspired great lettuce and broccoli crisis of 2017.

Some supermarkets are rationing the amount of iceberg lettuce and broccoli customers can buy – blaming poor growing conditions in southern Europe for a shortage in UK stores.

Tesco is limiting shoppers to three iceberg lettuces, as bad weather in Spain caused “availability issues”.

Morrisons has a limit of two icebergs to stop “bulk buying”, and is limiting broccoli to three heads per visit.

Asda said courgette stocks were still low after a UK shortage last month.

I guess we can expect higher prices here too as we mull whether the weather has ever affected food availability in the past! As a public service announcement there did not appear to be any shortage at Lidl at Clapham Junction yesterday. What will the Bank of England do about rising inflation? Well as you can see it takes a while to say “nothing”

At its February meeting, the MPC unanimously judged that it remained appropriate to seek to return inflation to the target over a somewhat longer period than usual, and that the current stance of monetary policy remained appropriate to balance the demands of the Committee’s remit.

If you are trading the US non-farm payroll numbers today then good luck….





20 thoughts on “The Forward Misguidance of Mark Carney and the Bank of England continues

  1. It is not much of a record, as you say, Shaun.
    Even the supine BBC pointed out yesterday that the BoE’s forecasts had moved rather a lot over the last few months.
    I have a theory as to why it has been so bad:
    1. Before 23rd June, Project Fear was in full swing;
    2. The “neutral” BoE forecast Armageddon and very soon if 23rd June went the “wrong way”;
    3. When it did go the wrong way, the BoE could hardly say that it had been joking all along about Armageddon;
    4. The BoE probably only talks to a very select group of the elite, who were all wringing their hands after 23rd and assumed doom was upon them;
    5. They assumed that everyone thinks like them and would stop shopping as the world crashed around them.
    This seems to be the only explanation for the policy positions taken since 23rd June. It can only be reversed when the BoE feels that it can plausibly take credit for saving us from becoming a wasteland.

    • I think you raise an important point about the value of a small unaccountable group trying to guess what will happen next. Whoever predicts the future is guessing, we are constantly reminded that ” past performance is no guide etc”. What we do know is that the larger the group the better the guess as in The Wisdom of Crowds.

      I believe that there are commercial companies who use the wisdom of crowds to provide “forward guidance”. Probably worth testing, can’t be worse.

  2. For those who don’t have to get up at 5.30, you will have missed Ben Broadbent on Radio 5 stating yet again that they didn’t get anything wrong. Its quite hard to learn from your mistakes when you are too pompous to admit that you have ever made any mistakes.

    • do not adjust your minds , reality is at fault …..

      (sighs) then they wonder why we think they are crap ……

      blaming “fake news” , the weather , anything or anyone …..


  3. Shaun, as a contrarian, I’m assuming that the BoE’s latest 2017 forecast of higher UK growth is bad news or, your thoughts on this matter would be appreciated, might it turn out to “surprise” on the upside again, and thus maintain the Governor’s magnificent mean squared forecasting error to date?

    • Hi Rob

      That thought has been troubling me too over the past 24 hours! I am expecting that it is in fact the inflation forecast where they will prove to be wrong. It certainly looks like that as we stand with current levels for the £ and for the oil price. As to growth if there is a danger it will come in the second half of 2017 from the same inflation rise.

  4. My greengrocer was saying last weekend that the price of courgettes and aubergines had rocketed due to recent heavy rain in Spain. She warned that oranges would be next and remain affected for up to 15 years because whole groves have had to be cut down and would take that long to regrow to fruit-bearing age. If nature wanted to send a message to Donald Trump about global warming they need a bette atlas!

    Shaun, thanks for exposing the well paid pompous fools at the BoE but I don’t expect any action to be taken because it’s too clubbable at that level.

      • Well, the pound did collapse against the dollar on 27/06/16 and then fell further following the rate cut a couple months later….

  5. ‘There is one aspect of Bank of England Forward Guidance which has in fact proved correct.

    the appropriate level of Bank Rate is likely to be materially below the 5% level set on average by the Committee prior to the financial crisis.

    I think we can say 0.25% is materially below 5%. But the rest of it has proven to be woeful. ‘

    If Carney had been this wrong in most businesses,he’d have been out of a job.

    • Hi Dutch

      I agree but of course the media tied its own hands with the way it lauded our “rockstar” Governor with the movie style looks and so on. From the economics editor of the FT Chris Giles.

      “How star central banker Mark Carney turned into a Brexit target” (30th of October)

      and well done Mark on September 23 rd

      “Mr Carney was sunk into gloom after the June 23 vote, having warned publicly on the economic risks of leaving the EU and viewing his role for the next two years as trying to patch up the fortunes of a diminished country. He has described the 24 hours after the referendum as his “toughest day” in the job.

      However, BoE insiders say the governor’s mood has brightened considerably, while he has won approbation in the City and at Westminster for his calm handling of the immediate fallout from the vote.”

      In fact that article read like something out of a press release.

      ““In the absence of anyone else showing much economic leadership, this gives him a chance to shine,” said one Whitehall official. “He quite likes the media opportunities his current job gives him on the world stage.””

  6. Hi Shaun, I tried to find news to support Tesco’s claim that their shortage was a European wide problem. Nout on bild or spiegel. From Die Welt – appears to be a British problem only.

    Supply and demand implies higher costs when items have lower supply and constant demand. Therefore I’d ask the question whether the weak pound and stretched profit margin is making it unprofitable for tesco to buy lettuce ? European lettuce shortage -> I just don’t believe it and I’ll check my local supermarket over the weekend ….

    Can anyone tell me whether the lettuce shortage includes Lidl UK, and whether they have price rises ?

  7. I think Carnage has already decided any rise in inflation will be temporary and can be looked through. So if inflation doesn’t trigger a rate change then it doesn’t matter what the inflation rate is ….

  8. So when Andrew Tyries inquiry into the the effectiveness and impact of the BoE’s monetary policy i.e printy printy and forever ZIRP comes back and shows the BoE’s destroying any chance of a working man being able to afford a house with his wages ….. is this bombshell likely to have an impact on rates or QE. May obviously pointed this out but has since gone quite after getting a telling off from her boss Carnage. Hoping this is her first move at implementing change.

    As i fall into this category and things just seem to be getting bleaker, and todays message from Tory HQ regards the housing white paper tells me we’re going to be renter scum for life to fund the pensions of our parents and bonuses of those in the City was a kick in the teeth.

    • Hi Arthur and welcome to my corner of the web.

      The UK establishment has pumped up house prices for ages so whilst I would love a report to be critical of this I would expect that some latterday Sir Humphrey would block things. But I live in hope…

      • Thanks often read your corner of the web, will keep quiet about though, as the powers that be might have you listed as a “Fake News” site for suggesting all is not perfect with UK PLC.

        I’m curious as to how the government are going to spin this and say the emergency measures that are QE, ZIRP along with FFL, TFS etc.. have not blown up asset prices to make the rich richer, when quite clearly they’ve blown up asset prices to make the rich vastly richer. (at the expense of the working under 45s who are now unable to afford a simple 3 bed semi, in most of Southern England)

        Its OK the un-elected, un-sackable riddle speaking Mr Carney speaking in his own special language to Rees Mogg at the Treasury Committee stating its Fiscal Policy causing the growing divide and not his Monetary policy .. but a politician who clearly thinks Carney is a useless #### and is putting his head above the parapet by doing such a report surely has to call a spade a spade.

        Any idea as to when its to be complete, i’ve tried Google but found nothing.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.