Where next for the Euro, the ECB and the Euro area economy?

In our new financial world where pretty much everything depends on the whims and moods of central bankers one of the main leaders is the ECB or European Central Bank. Yesterday we got one version of its future from the Governor of the Bank of Finland Ollie Rehn. So let me hand you over to his interview with the Wall Street Journal.

“It’s important that we come up with a significant and impactful policy package in September,” said Mr. Rehn, who sits on the ECB’s rate-setting committee as governor of Finland’s central bank.

“When you’re working with financial markets, it’s often better to overshoot than undershoot, and better to have a very strong package of policy measures than to tinker,” Mr. Rehn said.

That is pretty cleat although there is are two self-fulfilling problems in trying to overshoot financial markets. The first is that you are devolving monetary policy to financial markets. The second is that markets will now adjust ( they did so yesterday as I will discuss later) so do you overshoot that as well?

According to the WSJ these are the expectations Ollie was trying to overshoot.

Analysts expect the ECB will announce next month a 0.1 percentage-point cut to its key interest rate, currently set at minus 0.4%, as well as around €50 billion ($56 billion) a month of fresh bond purchases under its quantitative easing program. The program had previously been phased out at the end of last year.

There is already an example of the “slip-sliding away” as Paul Simon would put it that I mentioned earlier as the monthly bond purchases were expected to be 30 billion Euros a month. So which one would Ollie be overshooting?

Even worse for hapless Ollie others seem to have a different set of expectations.

Investors currently expect the ECB to cut its key interest rate to minus 0.7% and to hold rates below their current level through 2024, according to futures markets. Mr. Rehn said those market expectations showed that investors had understood the ECB’s guidance.

So will he now be overshooting -0.5% or -0.7%? Actually it gets better as -0.6% is in there now as well.

The comments suggest the ECB might cut interest rates by more than expected in September, perhaps by 0.2 percentage points, and could start to purchase new types of assets, Mr. Ducrozet said.

So roll up! Roll up! Place your bets on what Ollie will be trying to overshoot. Also as no doubt you have spotted whilst he may be in Finland he wants to start turning Japanese.

Mr. Rehn said he didn’t rule out a move to purchase equities under the QE program, but that would depend on the assessment of ECB staff.

That is a pretty shocking as the ECB staff assessment will be exactly what the Governing Council wants in the manner explained by The Jam.

You want more money – of course, I don’t mind
To buy nuclear textbooks for atomic crimes
And the public gets what the public wants

As I have acquired quite a few extra followers in the last week or two let me explain the Japan reference which is that the Bank of Japan has for a while now been purchasing Japanese equities. According to its latest accounts it now holds 26.6 trillion Yen of them.

The Problem

It is highlighted by this.

To provide space for fresh bond purchases, the ECB could adjust the rules of its bond-buying program, which currently prohibit the bank from buying more than 33% of the debt of any individual eurozone government, he added.

This is an example of what ECB President Mario Draghi calls it being a “rules-based organisation”. It is until they are inconvenient and then it changes them! One of the ways it got support for the previous QE programme was the limit above bit now it will be redacted from history. How high can it go? Well one example is from my own country the UK where the Bank of England does not have country limits ( for obvious reasons) but it does have a limit of 70% for each individual Gilt-Edged bond.

The Euro

Part of the plan behind Ollie’s interview was to talk down the Euro. After all the new “currency war” style consensus is to try a grab a comparative advantage in a zero-sum game. In a small way he succeeded as the Euro fell against most currencies. But there is a catch as highlighted by this release from Eurostat today.

As a result, the euro area recorded a €20.6 bn surplus in trade in goods with the rest of the world in June 2019…….In January to June 2019, euro area exports of goods to the rest of the world rose to €1 163.3 bn (an increase of
3.2% compared with January-June 2018), and imports rose to €1 061.2 bn (an increase of 3.7% compared with
January-June 2018). As a result the euro area recorded a surplus of €102.2 bn, compared with +€103.6 bn in
January-June 2018.

As you can see in the first half of the year trade created a demand for the Euro of around 102 billion Euros which is a barrier against any sustained fall. Actually this is a German thing because if you look at the national breakdown it accounts for 112 billion of this. Other nations such as the Netherlands run large surpluses assuming we look away from the “Rotterdam Effect” but as a collective in a broad sweep they contribute very little. So we get something very awkward which is that the main exchange rate fall came when Germany switched the Dm to the Euro. Since then there has been a lot of hot air on the subject but in terms of the effective exchange rate the Euro is at 98.3 or a mere 1.7% from where it started.

In a purist form I should look at the full current account but hopefully you have the idea from the trade figures. Partly I am doing that because I have very little faith in the other numbers.

Even more awkward for the ECB would be a situation where President Trump actually goes forward with his plan to buy Greenland. He would pay Denmark in its Kroner but as it is pegged to the Euro this would raise the Euro versus the US Dollar which is presumably part of the plan.

Comment

There is a lot to consider here but let me open with looking at the real economy. It is struggling with some but not much growth. So far in 2019 economic growth has gone 0.4% and then 0.2% on a quarterly basis. The fear is that it will slow further based on what was a strength above ( Germany’s trade surplus) which right now looks a weakness or as Frances Coppola out it.

Thread. Germany has been importing demand from China for a long time.

I am not saying it is the only perspective but it is one. On this road we have found little economic growth because even if we take the view of Mario Draghi this created a mere 1.5% of extra GDP growth. On the other side of the ledger is the destruction wreaked on all long-term contracts such as pensions and bond markets by the world of negative interest-rates. Oh and the fact if it had worked we would not be here.

As to the real economy well if we return to Ollie we see that in fact his main concern is “The Precious! The Precious!”

To offset the impact on eurozone banks of a longer period of negative interest rates, the ECB could introduce a tiered-deposit system, under which only a portion of bank deposits might be subject to negative rates, Mr. Rehn said.

The ECB could also alleviate the stress on banks by sweetening the terms of new long-term loans, known as targeted longer-term refinancing operations, he said.

If the real economy merits a mention I will let you know….

As a final point this version of economic management combining “open mouth operations” with reading a Bloomberg or Reuters screen to see where markets are often involves what have become called “sauces” saying something different, so be on your guard.

Meanwhile liuk on twitter has a suggestion which we can file under QE for millennials.

#ECB STAFF WILL INCLUDE AVOCADO FOR NEW ASSET BUYING PROGRAM

It would be a bit dangerous putting them in the Helicopter Money drop though…..

 

11 thoughts on “Where next for the Euro, the ECB and the Euro area economy?

  1. Hello Shaun,

    re: “It would be a bit dangerous putting them in the Helicopter Money drop though”

    ah but they’ll be paper/ promissory Avocados, redeemable at your local store , but move quick as they will depreciate against real avocados at 3.5% RPI linked .

    And those who have SMARTer ( than the owner) phones , your E-Avocado notes will redeem at 97% on issue ( !!) ……. then drop by RPI . Spend,spend spend , the Charlie Bean method!!

    Forbin

  2. It makes little difference what the ECB does to try and weaken the Euro – it simply won’t work, rates are already negative and lower to come, more QE? it doesn’t matter, the JCB have done it all before and bought 5% of their ETF’s and still can’t the yen down either, people think they are buying Deutschmarks when they buy the Euro so they don’t care what the rates are, they think if the Eurozone breaks up they will be left holding Deutschmarks,also there is the issue that currencies such as the pound are so weak fundamentally and with the threat of much lower levels to come from the BREXIT fiasco, it can only lose ground against it.

    • yah , esp if the Germans are the last one left…

      if they thought it would be France and the Frank……

      or perhaps Italy …. ummmmm

      Forbin,

      PS: I wonder if/when the Germans finally figured out that they ‘re the patsy for the Euro, what would they do ?

  3. Shaun,

    With interest rates going negative in more and more countries I don’t think anyone really has a good answer where all this will end up, Of course Japan has had negative rates for years but that doesn’t mean one can second guess how it would affect a different economy.

    I also read Blanchflowers blog on twitter he moans about high interest rates but I’m not sure whether he has an answer to sort the world problems out with the trillions of dent worldwide.

    What I found amusing today is he was complaining about the cost of a “stackable washer ” which he passed because it was to cost $3,000 https://twitter.com/D_Blanchflower/status/1162337365739880450

    Surely a professor in economics has a good income, as a matter of interest what would a professor in economics expect to earn?

    Presumably they would get paid for TV interviews and papers on top of fees paid by a University it the latter was their main income.

    I know he moved to the US because he wasn’t being paid enough in the UK as I have followed his posts for some time.

    As for the washer drier I think the guy has the wrong take as the one he has posted in a combined washer drier and DB was presumably looking for a separate washer drier to stack together.

    He thinks the tariffs increased the price but no one has answered his question. I am surprised however someone of his position had to consider the cost and decided not to proceed.

    If DB is struggling to make ends meet God help the average working class!

    • Hi Peter

      I do not know what a US professor would get. I did google Dartmouth College and it said US $138k but I do not know how accurate that is or whether Danny was able to negotiate a different deal. As to his tweets like all his output it is very political, so who knows whether he actually wanted one or he was having a dig at President Trump?

      • Hi Shaun,
        Presumably he tops up his pay with his papers, TV interviews and other work. But like everyone else even a professor in economics has to live and needs a house and everything else as well supporting his extended family and as such needs to watch his money.

        I am just a poor pensioner but could afford a stack on top Miele washer dryer if I needed to buy one.

        This is despite the UK pensions being only a small percentage of social security in the US which he has been posting on twitter over the weekend.

        Am just wondering who is worse of these days UK pensioners who watch the pennies or high paid professors who like the good things in life!

  4. Pingback: Where next for the Euro, the ECB and the Euro area economy - Free World Economic Report

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.