What can we expect next from the economy of France?

During the Euro area slow down France has mostly been able to avoid the limelight. This is because it has at least managed some economic growth at a time when Germany not always has. It may not be stellar growth but at least there has been some.

In Q2 2019, GDP in volume terms grew at the same pace as in the previous quarter: +0.3% (revised by +0.1% from the first estimate).

However  there are questions going forwards which plugs into the general Euro area problem which got a further nudge on Monday.

The IHS Markit Eurozone Composite PMI® fell to
50.4 in September according to the ‘flash’ estimate,
down from 51.9 in August to signal the weakest
expansion of output across manufacturing and
services since June 2013………The survey data indicate that GDP looks set to rise by just 0.1% in the third quarter, with momentum weakening as the quarter closed.

As you can see growth is fading and may now have stopped if the PMI is any guide and this was reflected in the words of the Governor of the Bank of France in Paris yesterday.

For the past ten years, there is little doubt that ECB monetary policy under Mario Draghi’s Presidency has made a decisive contribution not only to safeguarding the euro in 2012, but also to the significant recovery of the euro area since 2013. Over this period, more than 10 million jobs have been created. Our unconventional measures are estimated to add almost 2 percentage points of growth and of inflation between 2016 and 2020.

It is revealing that no mention is made of growth right now as he concentrates on what he considers to be past glories. He has rounded the numbers up too as they are 1.5% and 1.9% respectively. Let me give him credit for one thing though which is this although I would like him to say this to the wider public as well.

Since I am talking to an audience of researchers I should of course emphasise that such numbers are subject to uncertainty.

Also raising inflation in the current environment of weak wage growth is likely to make people worse and not better off.

France

The situation here was better than the Euro area average but still slowed.

At 51.3 in September, the IHS Markit Flash France
Composite Output Index fell from 52.9 in August,
and pointed to the softest expansion in private sector
activity for four months.

Actually manufacturing is doing okay in grim times with readings of 49.7 and 50.3 suggesting flatlining. The real fear here was that the larger services sector is now being sucked lower by it.

However, with services firms registering their
slowest rise in activity since May, fears of negative
spill over effects from the manufacturing sector are
coming to fruition. Any intensification of such effects
would likely dampen economic growth going
forward.

This leaves me mulling the record of Markit in France as several years ago it was criticised for being too pessimistic by the French government and more recently seems to have swung the other way.

What about fiscal policy?

This did get a mention in the speech by the Governor of the Bank of France yesterday.

Failing that, a second answer is for fiscal policy to step in. Fiscal stimulus from countries with fiscal space would both stimulate aggregate demand, and, with targeted, quality investment, increase long-term growth.

The problem with that argument is that even the French run IMF could not avoid pointing out this in July.

France’s public debt has been consistently rising over the last four decades, increasing by 80 percent of GDP since the 1980s to reach close to 100 percent of GDP at end-2018. This reflects the inability of successive governments to take full advantage of good times to reverse the spending increases undertaken during downturns.

Actually some of the IMF suggestions look rather chilling and perhaps in Orwellian language.

rationalizing spending on medical products and hospital services; improving the allocation of resources in education

Also and somewhat typically the IMF has missed one change in the situation which is that at present France is being paid to borrow. It’s ten-year yield went negative at the beginning of July and has mostly been there since. As I type this it is -0.32%. It still has to pay a little for longer terms ( the thirty-year is 0.48%) but as you can see not much.

So the situation is that France does have quite a lot of relatively expensive debt from the past but could borrow now very cheaply if it chose to do so.

Banks

Whilst he s referring to macroprudential policy it is hard not to have a wry smile at this from the Governor of the Bank of France.

 To start with, as of today, our toolkit is very much bank-centric.

Especially when he add this.

We are making some progress to extend macroprudential policy beyond the banking sector.

Returning to the banks they are just like elsewhere.

PARIS (Reuters) – Societe Generale (SOGN.PA) plans to cut 530 jobs in France by 2023, CGT union said in a statement.

Of course BNP Paribas has been taking some brokerage business and employees from Deutsche Bank although it has not be a complete success according to financemagnate.com.

Deutsche’s clients will receive letters explaining how the transfer will work. However, some of them have already moved to competitors such as Barclays, which has won roughly $20 billion in prime brokerage balances.

In a way the French banks have used Deutsche Bank as a shield. But many of the same questions are in existence here. How are they going to make sustained profits in a world of not much economic growth and negative interest-rates?

Unemployment

This is the real achilles heel of the French economy. From Insee

The ILO unemployment rate decreased by 0.2 points on average in Q2 2019, after a 0.1 points fall in the first quarter. It stood at 8.5% of the labour force in France (excluding Mayotte), 0.6 points below its Q2 2018 level and its lowest level since early 2009.

Whilst the falls are welcome it is the level of unemployment and the fact it is only now approaching the pre credit crunch levels which are the issue as well as this.

Over the quarter, the employment rate among the youth diminished (−0.3 points),

Whilst the unemployment rate for youth fell by 0.6% to 18.6% it is still high and the falling employment rate is not the best portent for the future.

Comment

So far the economy of France has managed to bumble on and unlike the UK and Germany avoided any quarterly contractions in economic output. If you look at this morning’s official survey then apparently the only way is up baby.

In September 2019, households’ confidence in the economic situation has increased for the ninth consecutive month. At 104, the synthetic index remains above its long-term average (100), reaching its highest level since January 2018.

Perhaps the fall in unemployment has helped and a small rise in real wages. The latter are hard to interpret as a change at the opening of the year distorted the numbers.

firms might pay a special bonus for purchasing power (PEPA) in the first quarter of 2019, to employees earning less than 3 times the minimal wage.

According to the official survey published yesterday businesses are becoming more optimistic too.

In September 2019, the business climate has gained one point, compared to August. The composite indicator, compiled from the answers of business managers in the main sectors, stands at 106, above its long-term mean (100)

So there you have it everything except for the official surveys points downwards. In their defence the official surveys have been around for a long time. So let me leave you with some trolling by the Bank of France monthly review.

French economic growth has settled into a fairly stable pace since mid-2018 of between 1.2% and 1.4% year-on-year . France has thus demonstrated greater resilience than other euro area economies, particularly Germany, where year-on-year growth only amounted to 0.4% in mid-2019. This growth rate should continue over the coming quarters: based on Banque de France business surveys published on 9 September, we expect quarter-on-quarter GDP growth in the third quarter of 2019 of 0.3%.

Rethinking The Dollar

I did an interview for this website. Apologies if you have any issues with the sound as the technology failed us a little and we had to switch from my laptop to my tablet.

 

 

 

 

Some much needed better economic news for France

Today has brought some good news for the economy of France and let us start with a benefit for the future. From Reuters.

Airbus signed a deal on Monday to sell 300 aircraft to China Aviation Supplies Holding Company, including 290 A320 planes and 10 A350, the French presidency said in a statement.

So we learn that someone can benefit from a trade war as we also see Boeing’s current problem with the 737 max 8 no doubt also at play here. Airbus is a European consortium but is a major factor in the French economy and below is its description of its operations in France.

Overall, Airbus exports more than €26 billion of aeronautical and space products from France each year, while placing some €12.5 billion of orders with more than 10,000 French industrial partners annually.

Business surveys

The official measure released earlier told us this.

In March 2019, the business climate is slightly more favorable than in February. The composite indicator, compiled from the answers of business managers in the main sectors, has gained one point: it stands at 104, above its long-term mean (100).

If we look at the recent pattern we see a fall from 105 in November to 102 in December where it remained in January before rising to 103 in February and now 104 in March. So according to it growth is picking up. It has a long track record but is far from perfect as for example the recent peak was 112 in December 2017 but we then saw GDP growth of only 0.2% in the first quarter of 2018 as it recorded 110.

Continuing with its message today we are also told this about employment.

In March 2019, the employment climate has improved again a little, after a more marked increase in February: the associated composite indicator has gained one point and stands at 108, well above its long-term average.

This is being driven by the service sector.

Also things should be improving as we look ahead.

The turning point indicator for the French economy as a whole remains in the area indicating a favourable short-term economic outlook.

Although the reading has fallen from 0.7 in January to 0.5 in March.

Economic Growth

We have been updated on this too with a nudge higher.It did not come with the fourth quarter number for Gross Domestic Product ( GDP) growth which was still 0.3% but the year to it was revised up to 1% from 0.9% and the average for 2018 is now 1.6% rather than 1.5%.

National Debt

The economic growth has helped with the relative number for the national debt.

At the end of 2018, the Maastricht debt accounted for €2,315.3 bn, a €56.6 bn year-on-year growth after a €70.2 bn increase in 2017. Maastricht debt is the gross consolidated debt of the general government, measured at nominal value. It reached 98.4% of GDP at the end of 2018 as in 2017.

As you can see the debt has risen but the economic growth has kept the ratio the same. At the moment investors are sanguine about such debt levels with the ten-year yield a mere 0.37% and it has been falling since mid October last year when it was just above 0.9%. Partly that is to do with the ECB buying and now holding onto some 422 billion Euros of it plus mounting speculation it may find itself buying again.

Those who followed the way the European Commission dealt with Italy may have a wry smile at this.

In 2018, public deficit reached −€59.6 bn, accounting for −2.5% of GDP after −2,8% of GDP in 2017

With economic growth slowing and President Macron offering a fiscal bone or two to the Gilet Jaunes then 2019 looks like it will see a rise. As to the overall situation then France has a public sector which fits the description, hey big spender.

As a share of GDP, revenues decreased from 53.6% to 53.5%. Expenditure went down from 56.4% to 56.0%.

For comparison the UK national debt under the same criteria is 84% of GDP although our bond yield is higher with benchmark being 1%.

Prospects

The Bank of France released its latest forecasts earlier this month and if we stay in the fiscal space makes a similar point to mine.

After a period of quasi-stability in 2018 at 2.6% of GDP, the government deficit is expected to climb temporarily above 3% of GDP in 2019, given the one-off effect related to the transformation of the Tax Credit for Competitiveness and Employment (CICE).

So the national debt will be under pressure this year and depending on economic growth the ratio could rise to above 100%. As to economic growth here is the detail.

French GDP should grow by around 1.4-1.5% per year between 2019 and 2021. This growth rate, which has been slightly revised since our December 2018 projections, should lead to a gradual fall in unemployment to 8% in 2021.

So the omission of the word up means the revision was downwards and if they are right then we also get a perspective on the QE era as GDP growth will have gone 2.3%,1.6% and then 1.4/1.5%. So looked at like that it was associated with a rise in GDP of 1%. Also we see the Bank of France settling on what is something of a central banking standard of 1.5% per annum being the “speed limit” for economic growth.

Right now they think this.

Based on the Banque de France’s business survey published on 11 March, we estimate GDP growth of 0.3% for the first quarter of 2019.

Which apparently allows them to do a little trolling of Germany.

The deceleration in world demand is expected to weigh on activity, even though France is slightly less exposed than some of its larger euro area partners, until mid-2019.

It only has one larger Euro area partner.

Also we get a perspective in that after a relatively good growth phase should the projections have an aim that is true unemployment will be double what it is in the UK already.

Added to this we have central banks who claim to have a green agenda but somehow also believe that growth can keep coming and is to some extent automatic.

Growth should then be sustained by an international environment that is becoming generally favourable once again and export market shares that are expected to stabilise.

Oh and these days central banks are what Arthur Daley of Minder would call a nice little earner.

Like each year, the bulk of the Banque de France’s profits were paid to the government and hence to the national community in the form of income tax and dividends, with EUR 5 billion due for 2017.

Comment

There is a fair bit to consider here. Firstly we have the issue of the private-sector or Markit PMI survey being not far off the polar opposite of the official one.

At the end of the first quarter, the French private
sector was unable to continue the recovery seen in
February, as both the manufacturing and service
sectors registered contractions in business activity.

If they surveyed a similar group that is quite a triumph! The French economy can “Go Your Own Way” as for example we saw it grow at a quarterly rate of 0.2% in the first half of 2018 and then 0.3% in the second. Only a minor difference but the opposite pattern to elsewhere.

Looking at the monetary data it does seem to be doing better than the overall Euro area. There was a sharp fall in M1 growth  between November and December which poses a worry for now but then a recovery of much of it to 9.2% in January. So if this is sustained France looks like it might outperform the Euro area as 2018 progresses as it overall saw a fall in money supply growth. Or if the numbers turn out to work literally then a dip followed by a pick-up.