How many central banks will end up buying equities?

Sometimes we can combine one of our themes with the news flow and today is an example of that. We can start with the role of central banks where what was considered extraordinary policy is now ordinary and frankly sometimes mundane. We have seen interest-rate cuts, then QE bond buying, then credit easing and of course negative interest-rates. Overnight even the home of the All Blacks has joined the latter party.

Some New Zealand wholesale rates fell below zero for the first time on Wednesday as investors increased bets on a negative policy rate. Two and three-year swap rates sank to minus 0.005%, as did the yield on the benchmark three-year bond. ( Bloomberg)

So we have negative bond yields somewhere else as the contagion spreads. Whilst it is only marginal the track record so far is that it will sing along with Madonna.

Deeper and deeper, and deeper, and deeper

Bloomberg thinks it is driven by this.

Most economists expect the RBNZ to cut its cash rate from 0.25% to minus 0.25% or minus 0.5% in April next year, and some see the chance of an earlier move.

However they seem to have missed the elephant in the room.

The Monetary Policy Committee agreed to expand the Large Scale Asset Purchase (LSAP) programme up to $100 billion so as to further lower retail interest rates in order to achieve its remit. The eligible assets remain the same and the Official Cash Rate (OCR) is being held at 0.25 percent in accordance with the guidance issued on 16 March. ( Reserve Bank of New Zealand 12 August)

So we are on the road to nowhere except according to Bloomberg it was a triumph in Sweden.

Negative rates were successful in Sweden because they achieved the aim of returning inflation to target without causing any significant distortions in the economy, said Lars Svensson, an economics professor in Stockholm and a former deputy governor at the Riksbank.

Only a few paragraphs later they contradict themselves.

Swedish mortgage rates dropped below 2%, causing house prices to surge to double-digit annual gains, but unemployment fell and the economy grew. Crucially, headline inflation rose steadily from minus 0.4% in mid-2015 to meet the central bank’s 2% target two years later. Inflation expectations also rose.

And again.

The Riksbank sent its policy rate into negative territory in early 2015, reaching a low of minus 0.5% before raising it back to zero late last year.

It worked so well they raised interest-rates in last year’s trade war and they have not deployed them in this pandemic in spite of GDP falling by 8%!

Oh and there is the issue of pensions.

In Sweden, the subzero-regime was advantageous for borrowers but brutal for the country’s pension industry, which struggled to generate the returns needed when bond yields turned negative.

So in summary we arrive at a situation where in fact even the Riksbank of Sweden has gone rogue on the subject of negative interest-rates. Going rogue as a central bank is very serious because they are by nature pack animals and the very idea of independent thought is simply terrifying to them.

Also the Riksbank of Sweden is well within the orbit of the supermassive black hole for negativity which is the European Central Bank or ECB. We learn much I think by the fact that in spite of economic activity being in a depression no-one is expecting an interest-rate cut from the present -0.5%. When we did have some expectations for that it was only to -0.6% so even the believers have lost the faith. This is an important point as whilst the Covid-19 pandemic has hit economies many were slowing anyway.

Policy Shifts

We are seeing central banks start to hint at ch-ch-changes.

Purchases of foreign assets also remain an option.

The Governor of the Bank of England Andrew Bailey has also been on the case and the emphasis is mine.

But one conclusion is that it could be preferable, and consistent with setting monetary conditions
consistent with the inflation target, to seek to ensure there is sufficient headroom for more potent expansion
in central bank balance sheets when needed in the future – to “go big” and “go fast” decisively.

He then went further.

That begs questions about when does the need for headroom become an issue? What are the limits? One
way of looking at these questions is in terms of the stock of assets available for purchase.

He refers to UK Gilts ( bonds) but he is plainly hinting at wider purchases.

Swiss National Bank

This has become something of a hedge fund via its overseas equity purchases. For newer readers this all started with a surge in the Swiss Franc mostly driven by the impact of the unwinding of the “Carry Trade” where investors had borrowed Swiss Francs. The SNB promised “unlimited intervention” before retreating and now as of the end of June had 863.3 billion Swiss Francs of foreign currency assets. It did not want to hold foreign currency on its own so it bought bonds. But it ended up distorting bond markets especially some Euro area ones so it looked for something else to buy. It settled on putting some 20% of its assets in equities.

Much of that went to the US so we see this being reported.

Swiss National Bank is one of the leading tech investors in the world. 28% of SNB’s Equity portfolio is allocated to tech stocks. Swiss CenBank has 17.4mln Apple shares worth $6.3bn or 538k Tesla shares worth $630mln. ( @Schuldenshelder )

So this is a complex journey on which we now note an issue with so-called passive investing. The SNB buys relative to market position but that means if shares have surges you have more of them each time you rebalance. So far with Apple that has been a large success as it has surged above US $2 trillion in market capitalisation as the recent tech falls are minor in comparison.But the 20% fall in Tesla yesterday maybe a sign of problems with this sort of plan. It of course has surged previously but it seems to lack any real business model.

The Tokyo Whale

The Bank of Japan bought another 80.1 billion Yen of Japanese equities earlier today as it made its second such purchase so far this month. As of the end of last month the total was 33,993,587,890,000 Yen. Hence its nickname of The Tokyo Whale.

Quite what good this does ( apart from providing a profit for equity investors) is a moot point? After all the Japanese economy was shrinking again pre pandemic and there was no sign of an end to the lost decades.

Comment

We find ourselves in familiar territory as central bankers proclaim the success of their polices but are always expanding them. If they worked it would not be necessary would it? For example the US Federal Reserve moving to average inflation targeting would not be necessary if all the things they previously told us would work, had. I expect the power grab and central planning to continue as they move further into fiscal policy via the sort of subsidies for banks provided by having a separate interest-rate for banks ( The Precious! The Precious!) like the -1% provided by the ECB. Another version of this sort of thing is to buy equities as they can create money and use it to support the market.

The catch of this is that they support a particular group be it banks or holders of assets. So not only does the promised economic growth always seem to be just around the corner they favour one group ( the rich) over another ( the poor). They have got away with it partly by excluding asset prices from inflation measures, but also partly because people do not fully understand what is taking place. But the direction of travel is easy because as I explained earlier central bankers are pack animals and herd like sheep. They will be along…..

17 thoughts on “How many central banks will end up buying equities?

  1. Shaun

    Well Japan has been buying equities for a long while now but its not affected productivity which is the main driver for an improved economy.

    However I can understand buying equities if they become too cheap and prevent good undervalues assets being snapped up by other countries.

    I also looked at the comments on your twitter site about Andrew Sentence being short of “fire power” !

    Well not really because interest rates haven’t gone negative in the UK as yet and I think they may have to be used as their other tools are limited.

    I don’t know whether they would work neither believe you can look to Japan as there are too many variables in each country and the effects will be different.

    But what is evidence is more countries are in fact going nearer to zero and indeed entering negative interest rates.

    Furthermore with BREXIT negotiations floundering in the UK and further lockdowns now imminent and to make things worse a halt on the OXFORD trials the future doesn’t look good for the UK at the moment.

    • It is quite normal for there to be isolated reactions to any medication in trials once you’re into the tens of thousands. It’s multiple reactions that are a worry and so far that hasn’t happened.

      • And its normal for big pharma to have 100% liability protection from Governments for this ‘vaccine’…….after you in the queue.

        • does make you wonder why it’s taking so long to get all that distilled water ready…..

          😉

          Forbin

          PS : a vaccine made from discarded common cold research if MSM is to believed.

          PPS : the vaccine for SARS-1 was shelved because the time it was ready for testing there were too few cases around for clinical tesing.

        • Im happy to be at the front of the queue. Better than the devastation Covid can wreak on the body. I have an acquaintance who had the virus in march and has gone from being a very fit 55 year old who regularly cycled 50 miles+ to someone who considers it an achievement to walk half a mile.

        • Big pharma (where I worked for many years) has agreed to supply vaccine at cost. The quid pro quo being that if you don’t make vast profits then you don’t accept liability that could bankrupt you. The trials are as thorough as ever but the regularity paper work is being rammed through at high speed. It is this part of clinical trials that takes so long as regulatory authorities work at the speed of continental drift. The companies are not ‘cutting corners’ it’s just that the authorities will review as fast as possible.

        • I have the flu jab every year , yah I know , just because I’m ok doesn’t mean everyone will be . example is my wife who gets really ill from the jabs so now does not have one

          Forbin

    • I would say: local governments & public services

      Companies get furlough payments and pass to employees
      Small Business get bounce-back loans

      Its not like America, where Govt sends RobinHood money to individuals.

  2. Shaun, your last paragraph says it all. I echo, folk don’t really understand the facade that is erected aorund their lives. Just occasionally they get a glimpse of reality.

    – a flat tyre from having driven into a hole
    – A beggar asks them for money, the beggar is hign on street drugs
    – A credit application is denied
    – Their paycheck barely covers standard out-goings when they look at their red bank balance

    Paul C.

    • Ah ‘reality’ , its all in the mind. The views of Scott Adams ( Gilbert fame).
      His definitions;
      Filter

      I use the word “filter” to describe the way people frame their observations of reality. The key idea behind a filter is that it does not necessarily give its user an accurate view of reality. The human brain is not capable of comprehending truth at a deep level.

      Second Dimension

      The second dimension describes the most common view of reality—the one in which we believe facts and logic are important to our decisions. This view says that humans are reasonable 90 percent of the time, but every now and then we get a bit crazy.

      Third Dimension

      The third dimension is where trained persuaders operate. This worldview says humans are irrational 90 percent of the time. The only exceptions are when decisions have no emotional content.

      Cognitive Dissonance

      Cognitive dissonance is a condition of mind in which evidence conflicts with a person’s worldview to such a degree that the person spontaneously generates a hallucination to rationalize the incongruity.

      Confirmation Bias

      Confirmation bias is the human tendency to irrationally believe new information supports your existing worldview even when it doesn’t.

      I think its increasingly clear to anyone that can think outside the box that we live in a Third Dimension world. it feels like ‘Alice through the looking glass’ to most who comprehend only in the Second Dimension.
      CBs behaviour; climate change; covid-19. Fear is the common denominator, the ‘persuaders’ use fear to control.

      • ” Cognitive dissonance is a condition of mind in which evidence conflicts with a person’s worldview to such a degree that the person spontaneously generates a hallucination to rationalize the incongruity.”

        Sums up the BoE nicely

        Forbin

  3. Alice arrives in NZ-

    Either the well was very deep, or she fell very slowly, for she had plenty of time as she went down to look about her, and to wonder what was going to happen next. ….
    ….Presently she began again. “I wonder if I shall fall fight through the earth! How funny it’ll seem to come out among the people that walk with their heads downwards! The antipathies, I think-“

    • Hi Eric

      “Please, Ma’am, is this New Zealand? Or Australia?”

      Perhaps she went to a gathering of central bankers.

      “But I don’t want to go among mad people,” Alice remarked.
      “Oh, you can’t help that,” said the Cat: “we’re all mad here. I’m mad. You’re mad.”
      “How do you know I’m mad?” said Alice.
      “You must be,” said the Cat, “or you wouldn’t have come here.”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.